Property Tax for Urban Assets - Taxes in Villena : Suma, NIE and general tax advice - Villena forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain
Airport Service Taxi Mil Palmeras  Torre de la Horadada
Gran Alacant Insurances
Thy Will Be Done
interior building work
Blacktower Financial Management
ASSSA Insurance
AA Free English TV
Car Key Solutions
Espana Dream Properties
Gentlevan Removals
James Spanish School
Jennifer Cunningham Insurances SL
Expat Services
Costa Blanca Building Specialists

Join the Villena forum

Join the Villena  forumMy name's Alex and this is my website all about Villena in Spain. Register now for free to talk about Taxes in Villena : Suma, NIE and general tax advice and much more!

Property Tax for Urban Assets

Posted: Tue Jul 18, 2017 10:32pm
12 replies285 views5 members subscribed
paulsav

paulsav

Super helpful member

Posts: 1376

1011 helpful points

Location: Villena

Joined: 4 Dec 2015

Hi, today I received a "Payment Required or else" notice from Suma re IBI, for 978.72€ which after taking a deep breath, thought No!, cant be right I pay by DD through Sabadell and we are up to date.I could make out it was for 2013-2016 didnt say it covered 2017 too so I emailed them. It appears this is an extra increased property taxation due to areas apparrantly not on the deeds which we had rebuilt (because of poor workmanship but no increase in footprint) in 2012 which we were actually conned by an interpreter who brought us an "architect?"who said the areas had been there over 4yrs(we purchased 5yrs earlier) so no planning needed just an application for "minor works" and he told interpreter what to request(actual list of works) which was duly applied for and approved 2mnths later. We were in Uk having agreed for builder (recommended by interpreter)to start work on approval being granted. What we only found out later was builder was told to abandon work by Town Hall architect at onset at the property, but he didnt and we paid up for work done 2mnths later.1yr later we were visited by Police and architect with a demolition order for 30days. After solicitor was unable to buy land to increase our land to comply with 2% rule so we could get it made legal we were stung for a 14,000€ fine. I,m not really questioning this situation it was a total nightmare at the time but this increase in IBI (after many emails with Suma) is because our original tax valuation was done in 1996, and from 2013 they were now charging us back tax on 74sq mts extra livable space not registered, (they wont allow it to be legal) and updated the valuation in 2015 and again updated in 2016 which is what property is rated on now.What a nerve, the 74sq mts have no value as illegal but they want tax as its still livable space and given property has reduced since crash they've increased the valuation.!.And why no earlier correspondence from them? I was wonderring if anyone else has experienced similar, and has your IBI massively increased because we used to pay 127€ for 116sq mts build and now I,m worried it will have gone up to around 300€.I cant work out their figures. Although I asked for a breakdown of the 978.72€,  they told me to get in touch with the Valuation Agency. I will email shortly our solicitor who handled the situation originally to see if he can get a breakdown but its extortionate if our IBI has doubled when others are still paying the original dated valuation (done 20yrs ago) and does that mean if you increase your property size not only do you pay tax on the extra space but you run the risk of the latest valuation rise. I didnt think they could charge tax on illegal builds but they do. I would gratefully appreciate someone who knows if this is correct(please no "know it all, but knows nothing" replies just to get their 2pennyworth in,) but I welcome any replies from interrested parties.

jimtaylor

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:40am

jimtaylor

Legendary helpful member

Posts: 5612

8739 helpful points

Location: Mudamiento

Joined: 2 Feb 2017

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:40am

Unfortunately I don't know enough to comment on the charge on illegal built areas.

IBI is based on the Catastral valuation of a property, and is supposed to be re-valued periodically. They were several years late in doing the revaluation on our property, and are allowed to backdate increased charges up to four years. 

The result was a nasty bill, and a tripling in the amount due for for 2016 as well as payment of the difference on previous years.

In some respects I'm grateful the property wasn't revalued when it should have been, as this would have been much more than four years ago, so for several years we had the benefit of cheap IBI.

Although I don't like the increased valuation, the bottom line is that I'm still going to be paying several times less than I would be paying for council tax in the UK.

paulsav

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 9:24am

paulsav

Original Poster

Super helpful member

Posts: 1376

1011 helpful points

Location: Villena

Joined: 4 Dec 2015

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 9:24am

Hi Jim, 

I,m so glad to hear I,m not alone in this experience (but sympathetic also). So from what you say, instead of a steady yearly increase as UK, they go a longer period and backdate upto 4yrs resulting in a much larger increase. However not every 4-5yrs which would make better sense. We got such a shock. So many people brag about their low cost IBI they may not know this happens, but it seems very selective to me and a point I was also trying to make is if construction works are carried out does this then initiate an upto date revaluation?.We are not residents (still in UK), and every day feel less likely to become one as we have experienced so many bad situations and corruptions, we fear the loss of security the UK still offers us. We know we,ll never be able to apply for UK benefits as our pensions etc are just above the limit but I still feel safer here knowing exactly whats around the corner. As you commented your tax tripled, sounds like ours will more than triple with the "unregistered area" now being taxed too.This could make it unaffordable to continue as a holiday home with our UK expenses too. Apart from water(similar price to UK) and electric(definitely a lot dearer)also paying 50€ mnth to Securitas( had 2 burglaries,1 a total ransacking with an insurance Co.refusing to pay out)and with insurance, gestoria fees and taxes its now getting very close to unaffordable. Our house is now 50ft from the AVE line and along with the drop in prices we stand little chance of selling even if we halved the initial buying price.

hallmon

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 9:25am

Posts: 26

5 helpful points

Location: Monóvar

Joined: 30 Oct 2015

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 9:25am

paulsav wrote on Tue Jul 18, 2017 10:32pm:

Hi, today I received a "Payment Required or else" notice from Suma re IBI, for 978.72€ which after taking a deep breath, thought No!, cant be right I pay by DD through Sabadell and we are up to date.I could make out it was for 2013-2016 didnt say it covered 2017 too so I emailed them. It appear...

...s this is an extra increased property taxation due to areas apparrantly not on the deeds which we had rebuilt (because of poor workmanship but no increase in footprint) in 2012 which we were actually conned by an interpreter who brought us an "architect?"who said the areas had been there over 4yrs(we purchased 5yrs earlier) so no planning needed just an application for "minor works" and he told interpreter what to request(actual list of works) which was duly applied for and approved 2mnths later. We were in Uk having agreed for builder (recommended by interpreter)to start work on approval being granted. What we only found out later was builder was told to abandon work by Town Hall architect at onset at the property, but he didnt and we paid up for work done 2mnths later.1yr later we were visited by Police and architect with a demolition order for 30days. After solicitor was unable to buy land to increase our land to comply with 2% rule so we could get it made legal we were stung for a 14,000€ fine. I,m not really questioning this situation it was a total nightmare at the time but this increase in IBI (after many emails with Suma) is because our original tax valuation was done in 1996, and from 2013 they were now charging us back tax on 74sq mts extra livable space not registered, (they wont allow it to be legal) and updated the valuation in 2015 and again updated in 2016 which is what property is rated on now.What a nerve, the 74sq mts have no value as illegal but they want tax as its still livable space and given property has reduced since crash they've increased the valuation.!.And why no earlier correspondence from them? I was wonderring if anyone else has experienced similar, and has your IBI massively increased because we used to pay 127€ for 116sq mts build and now I,m worried it will have gone up to around 300€.I cant work out their figures. Although I asked for a breakdown of the 978.72€,  they told me to get in touch with the Valuation Agency. I will email shortly our solicitor who handled the situation originally to see if he can get a breakdown but its extortionate if our IBI has doubled when others are still paying the original dated valuation (done 20yrs ago) and does that mean if you increase your property size not only do you pay tax on the extra space but you run the risk of the latest valuation rise. I didnt think they could charge tax on illegal builds but they do. I would gratefully appreciate someone who knows if this is correct(please no "know it all, but knows nothing" replies just to get their 2pennyworth in,) but I welcome any replies from interrested parties.

I offer no answers just wanted to thank you for pointing out what still can happen in Spain.  It does sound like a nightmare, I hope it is resolved fairly for you. Kind regards, Helen

paulsav

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 9:38am

paulsav

Original Poster

Super helpful member

Posts: 1376

1011 helpful points

Location: Villena

Joined: 4 Dec 2015

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 9:38am

Thankyou, I added my post mainly to inform people like yourself as to this happenning and hope someone who has "illegal areas" can comment on whether they still get taxed on that area as it isnt on the cadastral valuation(not being on the deeds).

Advertisement - posts continue below

starfox

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 10:07am

starfox

Helpful member

Posts: 86

54 helpful points

Location: Busot

Joined: 16 Feb 2015

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 10:07am

I can't offer many insights as your situation seems quite complex so contacting a lawyer is going to be your best bet.

One thing I will add however is the whole 4 year thing for declaring previously undeclared buildings  is now a relic of the past in the Valencian region and it is now set at 15 years. Look into the LOTUP rule changes as it is possible that this may be at least part of your issue.

Still our local town hall is still giving advice about the 4 year thing, it is wrong advice but the other day we went and a local was up in arms over the 3 grand increase to his suma bill over undeclared buildings. Maybe she was trying to calm him down but she was still stating if over 4 years old it wont be a problem, well now it is over 15 years so he will not be happy when he figures this out. She also said you have no idea of some of the complaints I have been getting.

A lot of this problem seems to stem from the brilliant idea of flying drones over areas and mapping properties with dodgy software which then somehow gives suma the right to alter your land registry to whatever it was the software made up. For instance they have reduced the size of our property boundaries enough to render our entire house illegal. They did this without notice(however told our lawyer they sent us a letter) and there is frankly nothing we can do about it aside from spending money to have a surveyor come and then reapply to the land registry which they say can take as long as 2 years leaving us out of pocket and with a property we can't build on or sell until it is sorted which is somehow our responsibility.

So yeah, I can't really offer any advice but get a good lawyer and hope for the best because even when your are not in the wrong you basically still have to pay up for their mistakes.

charliew

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 10:24am

charliew

Helpful member

Posts: 117

110 helpful points

Location: La Marina

Joined: 3 Aug 2016

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 10:24am

There is a very good English speaking Spanish solicitor in Villena.  His name is Carlos Hernandez Cantos and his phone number is 966 154 368 and email address is: [email protected]

I suggest you contact him. I'm sure he will be able to help you.

paulsav

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 10:25am

paulsav

Original Poster

Super helpful member

Posts: 1376

1011 helpful points

Location: Villena

Joined: 4 Dec 2015

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 10:25am

My goodness, what a terrible experience for you, yes the "architect" spouted wrongly the 4yr rule, but now it stays illegal because of shortage of land. Somewhere I read "if land anywhere in Spain was purchased then it could be tied to the houses' parcel to result in land big enough to legalise the property", but I cant remember where I read it or if its true. You are right, its unfair how its always our responsibility to pay for others mistakes.

starfox

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 10:36am

starfox

Helpful member

Posts: 86

54 helpful points

Location: Busot

Joined: 16 Feb 2015

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 10:36am

To be fair to the architect if this was pre 25th of July 2014 then that part of his advice would of been correct. The law changed as we were conveyancing a house which meant it was get in quick or get another evaluation afterwards. That house fell through for other reasons.

paulsav

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 10:38am

paulsav

Original Poster

Super helpful member

Posts: 1376

1011 helpful points

Location: Villena

Joined: 4 Dec 2015

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2017 10:38am

charliew wrote on Wed Jul 19, 2017 10:24am:

There is a very good English speaking Spanish solicitor in Villena.  His name is Carlos Hernandez Cantos and his phone number is 966 154 368 and email address is: [email protected]

I suggest you contact him. I'm sure he will be able to help you.

Thankyou Charlie for that info, we will contact him.We used a solicitor recommended by a neighbour originally but he comes from Alicante and isnt very communicative.(But he always manages to ask for money every visit!)

Sign up for free or login to reply to this topic

Want to reply to this topic? Login or register for free to post your message:

Find more Taxes topics from a particular area:


Register for free!

Login to your account

Airport Service Taxi Mil Palmeras  Torre de la Horadada
Gran Alacant Insurances
Thy Will Be Done
interior building work
Blacktower Financial Management
ASSSA Insurance
AA Free English TV
Car Key Solutions
Espana Dream Properties
Gentlevan Removals
James Spanish School
Jennifer Cunningham Insurances SL
Expat Services
Costa Blanca Building Specialists
Advertise your business here
Advertise your property
Help with my computer