Letting to friends and family - Page 5

Bee2 wrote on Sat Apr 15, 2023 6:14pm:

Davebev1 you were the person who told us in Spanish tax law you were required to report "all " gifts to the taxman and you were the person who said if you took any donation or gift for the use of your apartment/villa it was considered commercial letting.  That is not correct in Spanish tax l...

Read more...

...aw.The taxman didn't make any distinctions as to what your family or friends  could give you a donation, gift or loan for up to €6000. The orignal poster nor subsequent posters never had your interpretation of "letting". The post asked  "was it ok to let family and friends use your apartment" as subsequent posts made clear. There was never a question of renting it out as a commercial let to all and sundry and that has been my interpretation of it and my argument that a gift of whatever for using your apartment is not illegal nor does it make you a commercial landlord as you continue to insist. So I stand by what the taxman says about donations, gifts and loans from family and friends as it applies to the original poster and as it applies to family and friends using your holiday home and offering whatever as a thank you . That is not commercial letting and nor  is the taxman interested in these gifts or donations up to €6000.  I rest my case. I won't be adding any more to this topic.

Bee

Bee2 wrote on Sat Apr 15, 2023 6:14pm:

Davebev1 you were the person who told us in Spanish tax law you were required to report "all " gifts to the taxman and you were the person who said if you took any donation or gift for the use of your apartment/villa it was considered commercial letting.  That is not correct in Spanish tax l...

Read more...

...aw.The taxman didn't make any distinctions as to what your family or friends  could give you a donation, gift or loan for up to €6000. The orignal poster nor subsequent posters never had your interpretation of "letting". The post asked  "was it ok to let family and friends use your apartment" as subsequent posts made clear. There was never a question of renting it out as a commercial let to all and sundry and that has been my interpretation of it and my argument that a gift of whatever for using your apartment is not illegal nor does it make you a commercial landlord as you continue to insist. So I stand by what the taxman says about donations, gifts and loans from family and friends as it applies to the original poster and as it applies to family and friends using your holiday home and offering whatever as a thank you . That is not commercial letting and nor  is the taxman interested in these gifts or donations up to €6000.  I rest my case. I won't be adding any more to this topic.

Bee

Magicden wrote on Sat Apr 15, 2023 7:23pm:

Yes as you understood it was not about letting but but allowing friends family to use it occasionally for free. Thanks. 

Den. 

Bee2 wrote on Sat Apr 15, 2023 6:14pm:

Davebev1 you were the person who told us in Spanish tax law you were required to report "all " gifts to the taxman and you were the person who said if you took any donation or gift for the use of your apartment/villa it was considered commercial letting.  That is not correct in Spanish tax l...

Read more...

...aw.The taxman didn't make any distinctions as to what your family or friends  could give you a donation, gift or loan for up to €6000. The orignal poster nor subsequent posters never had your interpretation of "letting". The post asked  "was it ok to let family and friends use your apartment" as subsequent posts made clear. There was never a question of renting it out as a commercial let to all and sundry and that has been my interpretation of it and my argument that a gift of whatever for using your apartment is not illegal nor does it make you a commercial landlord as you continue to insist. So I stand by what the taxman says about donations, gifts and loans from family and friends as it applies to the original poster and as it applies to family and friends using your holiday home and offering whatever as a thank you . That is not commercial letting and nor  is the taxman interested in these gifts or donations up to €6000.  I rest my case. I won't be adding any more to this topic.

Bee

Davebev1 wrote on Sat Apr 15, 2023 9:09pm:

The person who first posted has made it clear he is happy with the regulations and understands them and is not taking payment. Letting and using for free are two different things. 

Bee2 wrote on Sat Apr 15, 2023 6:14pm:

Davebev1 you were the person who told us in Spanish tax law you were required to report "all " gifts to the taxman and you were the person who said if you took any donation or gift for the use of your apartment/villa it was considered commercial letting.  That is not correct in Spanish tax l...

Read more...

...aw.The taxman didn't make any distinctions as to what your family or friends  could give you a donation, gift or loan for up to €6000. The orignal poster nor subsequent posters never had your interpretation of "letting". The post asked  "was it ok to let family and friends use your apartment" as subsequent posts made clear. There was never a question of renting it out as a commercial let to all and sundry and that has been my interpretation of it and my argument that a gift of whatever for using your apartment is not illegal nor does it make you a commercial landlord as you continue to insist. So I stand by what the taxman says about donations, gifts and loans from family and friends as it applies to the original poster and as it applies to family and friends using your holiday home and offering whatever as a thank you . That is not commercial letting and nor  is the taxman interested in these gifts or donations up to €6000.  I rest my case. I won't be adding any more to this topic.

Bee

Bee2 wrote on Sat Apr 15, 2023 6:14pm:

Davebev1 you were the person who told us in Spanish tax law you were required to report "all " gifts to the taxman and you were the person who said if you took any donation or gift for the use of your apartment/villa it was considered commercial letting.  That is not correct in Spanish tax l...

Read more...

...aw.The taxman didn't make any distinctions as to what your family or friends  could give you a donation, gift or loan for up to €6000. The orignal poster nor subsequent posters never had your interpretation of "letting". The post asked  "was it ok to let family and friends use your apartment" as subsequent posts made clear. There was never a question of renting it out as a commercial let to all and sundry and that has been my interpretation of it and my argument that a gift of whatever for using your apartment is not illegal nor does it make you a commercial landlord as you continue to insist. So I stand by what the taxman says about donations, gifts and loans from family and friends as it applies to the original poster and as it applies to family and friends using your holiday home and offering whatever as a thank you . That is not commercial letting and nor  is the taxman interested in these gifts or donations up to €6000.  I rest my case. I won't be adding any more to this topic.

Bee