Posted: Wed Mar 13, 2024 10:47am
Somewhat unnecessary inflammatory language in that post regarding the use of S1 and GHIC.
If you're entitled to an S1 having paid into the UK system but then choose to live abroad then using language such as "defraud" is clearly nonsense as that carries criminal connotations.
I would have more understanding of your point if you said there are people using GHIC who are living under the radar permanently in Spain. I've no idea what this number is but I'm sure there are a few - but I suspect them to be a very small and ever decreasing minority especially since Brexit tightened up the border control position.
For those travelling to Spain from the UK and within the confines of the regulations and having a validly issued GHIC, then again I don't see that as any form of fraud.
Lastly, on the point of maintaining private health care provision whilst also having legitimate access to state provided healthcare, then that is clearly a personal choice and that added costs likely comes with increased flexibility either in terms of speed of access or in terms of where one is treated.