Life in Spain post Brexit - Brexit and the EU: living, holidaying and moving to Benidorm - Benidorm forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain
Thy Will Be Done
AA Free English TV
Expat Services
Costa Blanca Building Specialists
interior building work
Espana Dream Properties
Jennifer Cunningham Insurances SL
Car Key Solutions
Gentlevan Removals
James Spanish School
Blacktower Financial Management
Airport Service Taxi Mil Palmeras  Torre de la Horadada
POSITIVE BELIEFS
ASSSA Insurance
Gran Alacant Insurances

Join the Benidorm forum

Join the Benidorm forumMy name's Alex and this is my website all about Benidorm in Spain. Register now for free to talk about Brexit and the EU: living, holidaying and moving to Benidorm and much more!

Life in Spain post Brexit - Page 12

Davebev1

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:24pm

Davebev1

Legendary helpful member

Posts: 1591

2237 helpful points

Location: Playa Flamenca

Joined: 7 Nov 2017

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:24pm

Gemily1 wrote on Fri Jan 15, 2021 11:49am:

Is that why Boris got an 80 seat majority because 57% of the vote went elsewhere, I'll have to think about that one.

But you are right it is old news and instead of dwelling on the past we should concentrate on the future, because the past is History.

Yes, the Cons got an 80 seat majority while 57% of the vote went elsewhere in December 2019 - fact.  Those figures were available the day after the election and every day since, so not sure why you do not know about it or why you are questioning it.  Do you not understand the UK's undemocratic and out-dated FPTP system for electing MPs (as opposed to a more democratic and more representative system of PR)? 

alavib

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:24pm

alavib

Helpful member

Posts: 254

138 helpful points

Location: La Marina

Joined: 22 Sep 2017

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:24pm

And you think all that has stopped no not at all, go and see the illegal immigrants detention centers all over SE England and see they are full of exactly the types you mentioned and they are still coming in by boat loads and UK government has no answer as to how to control it or indeed stop it

We has changed is that we are now receiving more economical migrants rather than the resourceful eur

sheilaheggarty

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:35pm

sheilaheggarty

Helpful member

Posts: 156

204 helpful points

Location: La Mata

Joined: 5 Sep 2020

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:35pm

Davebev1 wrote on Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:18pm:

1. The Uk did not and never has had uncontrolled immigration.  The UK had the right to control it's borders while in the EU and EU migration rules could have been enforced.

2.  You are more likely to find an immigrant working in the the NHS than 'swamping' it 

3.  There are far more Brits convicted of crimes than immigrants and to suggest that people travel to the UK to commit such awful crimes as rape and murders is both unfounded and racist.

3. The minimum wage is set by the government.  Maybe instead of complaining about immigrants you should start a campaign to raise the minimum wage.

4. immigrants are not first in line for council houses.

5.  I suspect from your comment that you have no idea of the legal differences between, and the laws covering, immigrants, refugees and asylum seekers.  It is precisely that lack of knowledge that the UK government should address and start to include such subjects in the basic education.  It wasn't 'immigration' but lack of understanding about the rules, and in some cases the lack of implementation of the rules, that led to the racist element in the brexit vote - the idea (openly perpetuated by certain tabloids with dramatic but inaccurate headlines) that somehow immigration is a bad thing, plus all refugees or asylum seekers (and those papers treat the words as interchangeable when they are not) are somehow arriving illegally and taking advantage of the UK.

6. Can you please provide credible links to any of your claims?

Again another reasoned , logical, and informed response. 🍷

Davebev1

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:39pm

Davebev1

Legendary helpful member

Posts: 1591

2237 helpful points

Location: Playa Flamenca

Joined: 7 Nov 2017

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:39pm

alavib wrote on Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:24pm:

And you think all that has stopped no not at all, go and see the illegal immigrants detention centers all over SE England and see they are full of exactly the types you mentioned and they are still coming in by boat loads and UK government has no answer as to how to control it or indeed stop it

We has changed is that we are now receiving more economical migrants rather than the resourceful eur...

...

You have just demonstrated that you do not understand the difference between an immigrant, a refugee, asylum seeker and an illegal immigrant.  Please educate yourself on the differences and the different laws that cover those people.  

For the record (and if you need it I can direct you to some of the relevant laws, treaties and court cases if you really, want to read through a few hundred pages of legal stuff), someone arriving on a dinghy from France is not actually arriving illegally, anyone can rock up to the UK in a boat.  They only become illegal if they do not take the first available opportunity to declare their arrival to the authorities, with or without proof of documentation of who they are or where they have come from.  

Absolutely no one has any idea how many illegal migrants live in any country - the are undocumented, unknown about, can't claim anything from the state, there is no record of them, and live below the radar. 

An asylum seeker does not have to seek asylum in the first 'safe' country in which they arrive.  That is established legal position as set out in the Genevre Convention and there were three precedent court cases and judgements in the Supreme Court in 1999 to confirm how the GC should be interpreted within British law.  Unless, of course, you can quote any change in that ruling - case number and details to be included.

Refugees are covered by other internationals laws and the UK takes fewer refugees than many countries.

Immigration has always been controlled - non-EU migrants were covered by existing UK laws and made up the higher portion of migrants.  EU-migrants had to comply with the rules surrounding FoM, which the UK chose not to enforce in many cases.

Paul

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:46pm

Paul

Helpful member

Posts: 400

333 helpful points

Location: Monóvar

Joined: 7 Feb 2016

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:46pm

AlanG wrote on Fri Jan 15, 2021 11:55am:

Are you suggesting the 11 million who didn’t vote would have been remain voters? meaning the result would have been different.  Flawed logic.

Not at all, I'm highlighting that the "will of the people" mantra is nonsense, it's just another slogan like take back control and get brexit done, the outcome was not clear and as I've stated it came on the back of the 2015 migrant crisis which Farage played on. The only clarity from the referendum was that over 16 million wanted to stay in the EU, 11 million were not too bothered and 17 million for a variety of reasons from the curvature of bananas, to some idea of lost sovereignty and everything inbetween.

Advertisement - posts continue below

Micmac

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:54pm

Posts: 8

8 helpful points

Location: Villamartin

Joined: 13 Jul 2020

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:54pm

Another point, which should not be forgotten, "ilegal" migrants into UK used to be returned using Dublin agreement this is now not available. 

Só migrants passing from a eu country cannot be returned to EU country they  left, another brexit "Bonus". 

George55

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:57pm

George55

Helpful member

Posts: 356

385 helpful points

Location: Villamartin

Joined: 29 Dec 2020

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:57pm

Davebev1 wrote on Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:24pm:

Yes, the Cons got an 80 seat majority while 57% of the vote went elsewhere in December 2019 - fact.  Those figures were available the day after the election and every day since, so not sure why you do not know about it or why you are questioning it.  Do you not understand the UK's undem...

...ocratic and out-dated FPTP system for electing MPs (as opposed to a more democratic and more representative system of PR)? 

Worth noting on the point around FPTP, that there was a 2011 referendum on the introduction of STV (EDIT - as correctly pointed out, the referendum was on the AV system; I meant to write PR here but erroneously wrote STV so apologies for that) which was rejected by the British people by 68% to 32%. The turnout was very low but there was clearly no mandate by the British people to change the system.

So yes, the whole constituency FPTP system remains , which largely returns disproportionate majorities compared to the actual % vote. That is just as true now as it has been throughout its existence.

Paul

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 1:36pm

Paul

Helpful member

Posts: 400

333 helpful points

Location: Monóvar

Joined: 7 Feb 2016

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 1:36pm

George55 wrote on Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:57pm:

Worth noting on the point around FPTP, that there was a 2011 referendum on the introduction of STV (EDIT - as correctly pointed out, the referendum was on the AV system; I meant to write PR here but erroneously wrote STV so apologies for that) which was rejected by the British people by 68% to 32...

...%. The turnout was very low but there was clearly no mandate by the British people to change the system.

So yes, the whole constituency FPTP system remains , which largely returns disproportionate majorities compared to the actual % vote. That is just as true now as it has been throughout its existence.

We were not offered PR but AV, an alternative voting system, it was convoluted and most people just shrugged their shoulders and thought what's the point.

jm0452

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 1:52pm

jm0452

Helpful member

Posts: 85

98 helpful points

Location: La Zenia

Joined: 22 Mar 2017

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 1:52pm

Paul wrote on Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:46pm:

Not at all, I'm highlighting that the "will of the people" mantra is nonsense, it's just another slogan like take back control and get brexit done, the outcome was not clear and as I've stated it came on the back of the 2015 migrant crisis which Farage played on. The only clarity from the referen...

...dum was that over 16 million wanted to stay in the EU, 11 million were not too bothered and 17 million for a variety of reasons from the curvature of bananas, to some idea of lost sovereignty and everything inbetween.

I voted for brexit but the reason wasn't immigration it was uncontrolled immigration due to free movement which put strain on all of the UK services. It's ironic that due to the arrogance of Merkel not listening to the British people when David Cameron was in control.and acceptance of small changes brexit became reality.

AlanG

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 2:18pm

Posts: 8

16 helpful points

Location: Catral

Joined: 16 Sep 2019

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 2:18pm

Paul wrote on Fri Jan 15, 2021 12:46pm:

Not at all, I'm highlighting that the "will of the people" mantra is nonsense, it's just another slogan like take back control and get brexit done, the outcome was not clear and as I've stated it came on the back of the 2015 migrant crisis which Farage played on. The only clarity from the referen...

...dum was that over 16 million wanted to stay in the EU, 11 million were not too bothered and 17 million for a variety of reasons from the curvature of bananas, to some idea of lost sovereignty and everything inbetween.

What part of over a million people is ‘not clear’ the 11000000 who didn’t bother are irrelevant as there’s no way of knowing what they were thinking. Stop trying to justify your personal position/view and get behind the country, we can’t change the result so support positive progress, there’s no place for wingers.

Sign up for free or login to reply to this topic

Want to reply to this topic? Login or register for free to post your message:

Find more Brexit and the EU topics from a particular area:


Register for free!

Login to your account

Thy Will Be Done
AA Free English TV
Expat Services
Costa Blanca Building Specialists
interior building work
Espana Dream Properties
Jennifer Cunningham Insurances SL
Car Key Solutions
Gentlevan Removals
James Spanish School
Blacktower Financial Management
Airport Service Taxi Mil Palmeras  Torre de la Horadada
POSITIVE BELIEFS
ASSSA Insurance
Gran Alacant Insurances
Advertise your business here
Advertise your property
Help with my computer